Thursday 1 November 2012

Evaluation of previous students work


 Y = Yes

N = NO
- = partially

Evaluation of previous work
Performance
Narrative
Conceptual
Music&visuals
Lyrics&visuals
1.     What are the technical and stylistic strengths?
2.     What are the main weaknesses
3.     Does it meet conventions and expectations of:
-       genre of music
-       mage of artist
4.     What mark would you give it?

Kate nash – merry happy

Y
Y
-
Y
N
Variety of shots, editing fitted the song
Lip sync was bad
There is a love story in it
28/40                                          
Lazbo Bane – superman

Y
N
N
Y
-
Good shots and editing
Lip sync was bad, didn’t make any sense
20/40
Rumble Strips – hands

Y
N
Y
Y
Y
Creative and good shots
Some pointless shots, dragged on
26/40
Crystal Castles – Not in love    

Y
Y
N
Y
Y
Use of props was good, the reserve editing was good, it was very creative
Got every repetitive
There was a party and sunset which is conventional
34/40
Pendulem – Showdown

Y
N
Y
Y
Y
Good relationship between playing guitar and guitar hero
The performance/narrative is hard to understand
Music and instruments are heard and seen at the same time, game feel to the music
35/40
Articc Monkeys – This house is a circus

Y
-
Y
Y
Y
Good and performance sync, good conceptual ideas
Ending is sudden
The band are playing, the clowns are there in relation to circus
40/40






No comments:

Post a Comment